Answers to “why” may lead to better tailored treatments for breast cancer
All breast cancers are not created equal. Some are slow growing, while others are more aggressive and deadly, advancing at faster rates.
[African-American women] are often diagnosed at a younger age than other women and have a higher mortality rate.
African-American women get breast cancer less often than white women, but
if they are diagnosed with the disease, it is often more advanced and more
aggressive. They are often diagnosed at a younger age than other women and
have a higher mortality rate. This has puzzled doctors.
Looking for answers
Until now, we had guessed
that socio-economic factors were somewhat to blame. Were African-American
women getting early screening mammography? Did they have the same
access to health care their white counterparts had? How were their
nutrition and other health factors? But all this aside, even African-American
women who saw their doctors regularly and had annual mammograms,
but had breast cancer, tended to be diagnosed with more aggressive
forms of the disease.
Quite often, the women had higher-grade tumors
and cancers that were hormone receptor-negative. Hormone receptor-negative
signals a bad type of cancer. Since healthy breast tissue has hormone
receptor cells, if a tumor doesn't have receptor cells, it
is that much farther away from a normal cell. With all these differences
in breast cancer severity and mortality between the races, we
continued to ask, Why?
A biological component
This is an excellent study
because it helps answer some of our questions. We now know one
underlying biological component to the more aggressive cancer,
and that opens the door to a broader understanding of the disease.
More important, in the future it might lead us to develop better
tailored treatments.
In a nutshell: This study tells us that a genetic mutation to
the tumor suppressor gene p53 is one biological explanation. While
it's very complicated, basically tumor suppressor genes help
keep cancer away. P53 is one of about 10 genes that help suppress
all types of cancer.
[The] p53 gene has been found to be altered in African-American women four times as often as white women.
New tumor suppressor genes are being identified all the time. In most
cancerous cells, a suppressor gene has been lost or damaged. This p53 gene
has been found to be altered in African-American women four times as often
as white women. If the gene is mutated, it can't do its job to suppress
cancer.
Should I be tested?
Some women may be wondering
whether they should be tested to see if their p53 gene is mutated.
I don't think so. It's not a routine test, and knowing whether
your tumor has the mutation wouldn't affect your treatment or outcome
at this time. It's more of a first step for doctors to know who
gets the more aggressive types of breast cancer.
More research needed
Over the past 15 years, we have helped lower
the breast cancer mortality rate in white women but not in African-American
women. When we can better understand the biological causes, we
might be able to tailor treatments that fit the type of cancer.
The study is also creating a lot of buzz. But while this study
is exciting, as with any study, it points out the need for further
answers. A fair amount of money is spent each year on breast cancer
research, but it's never enough. It's my hope that
subsequent studies look at the difference in survival rates between
the groups of women and look for other similar biological markers.
With that information, we can offer women more promise for the
future.
Early detection key
This study shouldn't change a thing women dothey
still need to abide by their doctors' recommendations for
screenings and talk to their doctors about any concerns they
may have. Early detection remains the best defense.
Donald Lannin, MD, is co-director of the Yale-New Haven Breast Center and a professor of surgical oncology at Yale University School of Medicine.