|
May 25, 2005
News this month
Broken heart syndrome mimics heart attacks
Researchers at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore have found that emotional
trauma can result in the release of hormones that can stun the
heart, mimicking the symptoms of a heart attack. Stress cardiomyopathy or broken
heart syndrome, long a subject of folklore, has been observed primarily
among women who have undergone extreme stress such as the death of a loved
one or a car accident.
Emotional trauma can result in the release of hormones that can “stun” the heart, mimicking the symptoms of a heart attack.
Individuals who experience this syndrome have chest pain, shortness of breath,
fluid in the lungs and heart failure. The heart's ability to pump is
severely impaired, but the heart tissue itself is not damaged as in a heart
attack. The tissue is alive, says Dr. Hunter Champion who co-authored
the study published in the New England Journal of Medicine.
Study reveals unique patterns, but no disease
Champion and
fellow Hopkins cardiologist Ilan Wittstein had observed that a small number
of heart attack patients, usually postmenopausal women, had unique electrocardiograms
and ultrasound patterns and no evidence of coronary artery disease. They recovered
quickly from their attacks, which had been preceded by intense emotional events.
Between 1999 and 2003, the researchers studied 19 patients who had what appeared
to be traditional heart attacks after experiencing sudden emotional stress,
including news of a death, a surprise party, presence at an armed robbery and
a car accident. Most of the patients were in their 60s and 70s although one
was 27. All but one were female.
All of the subjects were evaluated with electrocardiography, cardiac enzyme
assessment, echocardiography and coronary angiography. Five patients underwent
a biopsy and another five had MRIs to determine if there had been damage to
the heart muscle.
Stress hormones were two to three times greater than those in classic heart attack patients and between 7 and 34 times greater than in healthy people.
Similarities to classic attack not complete
Although the symptoms
were similar to a classic heart attack, the similarities ended there. Stress
hormone levels were measured shortly after admission and compared with readings
taken at day 3, 5, 7 and 9 after the event. The initial levels of these stress
hormones, called catecholamines, were two to three times greater than those
in classic heart attack patients and between 7 and 34 times greater than in
healthy people.
Also, unlike heart attack sufferers there was no evidence of blockages in
the arteries supplying blood to the heart. Blood tests showed only mild elevation
of muscle proteins typically released after a heart attack. MRI imaging showed
none of the emotionally stressed patients suffered any permanent damage to
their hearts. There were also very rapid improvements in the pumping ability
of their hearts within a few days, and they were completely recovered within
two weeks, compared to heart attack victims whose recovery normally takes months.
Broken hearts require treatment
It is important,
the doctors stress, to treat the symptoms of broken heart syndrome. Three of
the 19 patients temporarily required a special balloon in the aorta to help
the heart pump better. Broken heart syndrome usually requires only short-term
treatment because the heart normally recovers by itself.
Second study confirms the effect of stress hormones
Stress
cardiomyopathy has been known for several years in Japan, but it has gone relatively
unrecognized in the West, according to Dr. Barry Maron, a cardiologist at the
Minneapolis Heart Institute Foundation. Maron described 22 similar cases in Circulation.
Our hypothesis is that massive amounts of these stress hormones can
go right to the heart and produce a stunning of the heart muscle that causes
this temporary dysfunction resembling a heart attack, Wittstein said. It
doesn't kill the heart muscle like a typical heart attack, but it renders
it helpless. It is important to support the heart during this vulnerable
period otherwise patients may die.

Physician Referral Online
A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.
Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database
of more than 1,000 area physicians who have registered to participate.
Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with a member
of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or call:
203-688-2000
or toll-free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.

|

|

Sudden stress can stun your heart
Physicians have been aware that traumatic events could result in a small but real number of patients suffering from sudden cardiac death, classic heart attack symptoms or abnormal cardiac rhythms. We’ve seen it after natural disasters such as earthquakes, as well as after an individual experiences some traumatizing event, most commonly the unexpected death of a loved one.
There are actual physical changes
taking place in the body due to severe emotional trauma.
This study is the first to provide us with evidence of biochemical markers
indicating there are actual physical changes taking place in the body due to
severe emotional trauma.
Women are more susceptible
Though we see this syndrome
in men and women, women tend to be more susceptible to the effect of sex hormones
on sympathetic nervous system activity and coronary spasm. The typical victim
is a woman, over age 50, usually postmenopausal, with no previous cardiac
disease who has undergone a lifetime crisis.
More than 70 percent of the time the precipitous event is a death. Patients
experience sudden chest pain and shortness of breath. Some are in profound
shock with very low blood pressure. Their hearts pump at about a third of
the normal capacity, similar to severely ill heart failure patients.
Study patients had no permanent damage
These patients in
the New England Journal of Medicine and the 22
women studied in the Circulation paper all had abnormal EKGs, some
had abnormal serum markers, but when their coronary arteries were examined,
only one showed evidence of clinically significant coronary disease. All of
the patients fully recovered with no heart damage within a few days.
When the broken heart syndrome patients were compared with heart attack patients,
the remarkable differenceaside from the absence of coronary diseasewas
the high level of stress hormones in their systems. These hormonesthe
catecholamines, which include adrenaline, noradrenaline and othersprepare
our bodies to meet emergencies such as cold, fatigue and shock.
[Stress hormones] can also be
temporarily toxic to the heart, stunning the muscle
.
They are responsible for the 'fight or flight' response that
enabled our ancestors to escape predators and other dangers. However, new
research shows that these chemicals can also be temporarily toxic to the heart,
stunning the muscle and producing the symptoms these patients experienced.
Heart stunning should be treated
If this heart stunning
is not treated, some people may die because the pumping action of the heart
is so weakened. That's why it's essential for individuals who are experiencing
these symptoms to seek emergency medical help immediately. There was a time
when physicians minimized these physical reactions to trauma, attributing
the symptoms to psychological causes. This study clearly shows the heart is
undergoing physical changes that need to be assessed and treated immediately.
When stress is chronic
Although this syndrome is a result
of an acute stressful event, there is evidence that chronic stress and long-term
anxiety also increase the risk of heart disease. There are several ways this
can happen. People who experience a lot of depression and anxiety may be less
likely to practice heart-healthy lifestyle habits such as exercise and weight
control than calmer individuals. They also may be more likely to smoke.
Chronic stress also predisposes people to cardiac arrhythmias and has a direct
effect in advancing atherosclerosis, the molecular basis for heart attacks.
Chronic anxiety, which results in the continuous elevation of catecholamines,
can also lead to the development of cardiac risk factors such as high blood
pressure, diabetes and high cholesterol.
For these reasons, it's important for people to get help for chronic
anxiety and stress since research also shows that management of long-term
anxiety can lead to better management of cardiac risk factors and the subsequent
decrease in the risk of coronary disease. It is critical for all individuals,
especially women, to know their risk factors for heart disease and to take
charge in controlling them.
Take action
It is important for you to be sensitive to what's
happening to your body. If you notice subtle feelings of being unwell, it
is very important to get checked out right away. Seek emergency care immediately
when experiencing any of the signs
or symptoms of a heart attack.
Get a second opinion if you feel that your symptoms are not being taken seriously
and be assertive in seeking help.
Dr. Safdar is the co-director of the Yale-New Haven Hospital Chest Pain Center and an assistant professor of emergency medicine at the Yale University School of Medicine.
|