U.S. cholesterol panel backs wide drug
treatment
It's been less than 10 years since the National Cholesterol
Education Program (NCEP) issued their last set of guidelines,
but two major thrusts have changed how we approach the treatment
of heart disease. First, we've learned aggressive treatment with
cholesterol-lowering drugs dramatically reduces the incidence
of disease; and second, abundant research and our own experience
confirm the safety, at least in the intermediate term, of statin
drugs.
"Aggressive treatment with cholesterol-lowering
drugs dramatically reduces the incidence of [heart] disease.…"
The data is compelling. In the 14 years since they were introduced
in the U.S., the statins have revolutionized the treatment of
heart disease. Study after study have shown these drugs prevent
heart attacks and prolong lives, with very few side effects.
About five million people currently take statins in this country,
and these new guidelines indicate even more people should be on
them, including not only those who already have heart diseaseor
a strong propensity for developing it, like diabetics or smokersbut
also those with moderately high levels of LDL cholesterol and
low levels of HDL.
Statin safety issue
When they were first introduced, there were many concerns about
the safety of statins. Physicians were reluctant to prescribe
them because of warnings about liver disease, but after several
studies, we have cumulative evidence that these drugs are safe
with relatively few side effects.
"Statins cause liver and muscle toxicity
in far fewer than 1% of patients, but we don't know if there are
any negative long-term effects.…"
Statins cause liver and muscle toxicity in far fewer than 1 percent
of patients, but we don't know if there are any negative long-term
effects that might manifest themselves after 20 or 30 years. We
do know these drugs save lives, and because of their safety, we
are now treating both younger and older patients.
If your cholesterol levels are moderate
For those with moderate cholesterol levels (LDL levels
> 130 mg/dL) who are at lower risk for heart disease10 to
20 percent according to the new NCEP formulaour approach
continues to be to recommend therapeutic lifestyle changes (TLC).
These changes include eating less fat and more fiber to lower
LDL and control weight and increasing exercise to raise HDL and
control weight.
If these measures are not successful, we would consider beginning
drug therapy for those whose risk factors are in the 10 to 20
percent range. For those with a less than 10 percent risk, we
might consider drug therapy if LDL levels are 160 mg/dL or higher.
New category of people to receive aggressive treatment
Probably the biggest change is that we would now treat those with
a 20 percent or higher risk due to cholesterol as aggressively
as those who have already had a heart attackusually with
cholesterol-lowering drugs as well as TLC. People with diabetes
are automatically placed in the high-risk category because recent
research identifies this disease as such a danger sign for heart
disease.
"Adults should have a lipoprotein
profile. . .every five years."
New look at "good cholesterol" (HDL)
The new guidelines also underscore the fact that a total cholesterol
reading doesn't tell the whole story. Adults should have a lipoprotein
profile to identify LDL, total cholesterol, HDL and triglycerides
every five years. We now identify low HDL levels as anything less
than 40 mg/dL. The change reflects new findings about the strong
link between a low HDL and an increased risk of heart disease.
An HDL level of 60 mg/dL or more is considered protective against
heart disease. [See: Want
to lower your risk? Try raising your levels of good cholesterol,
March 2000]
Statin drugs do little to raise HDL, but drug companies now have
drugs in their pipelines that target HDL, so we might see something
new within the decade that will make it possible to treat low
HDL effectively. Exercise and smoking cessation are somewhat helpful
in raising HDL levels.
Ugly triglycerides
Elevated triglycerides are also significantly linked to heart
disease. The new guidelines recommend treating even borderline
levels with weight control, medications and diets that exclude
alcohol.
Metabolic syndrome
At least one in every four American adults has metabolic syndrome,
which places them in high-risk categories for both heart disease
and diabetes. This includes three of the following:
- abdominal obesity (for men that means
a waist of 40 inches or larger; for women, 35 inches or more)
- triglycerides higher than 160 milligrams
- HDL less than 40
- blood pressure higher than 130/85 millimeters
- fasting blood sugar greater than 110 milligrams
Exercise and diet, as well as treatment to reduce blood pressure
and lower lipid counts, are indicated.
"Hormone replacement therapy is not
a substitute for cholesterol-lowering drugs."
What about hormone replacement therapy?
We have known for decades that estrogen has a protective effect
on premenopausal women. Women generally develop heart disease
10 years later than men after menopause. However, recent research
indicates that hormone replacement therapy is not a substitute
for cholesterol-lowering drugs.
In fact, statins have beneficial effects on strengthening bone
for women at risk of osteoporosis. After a woman has had a heart
attack, HRT is generally not recommended because it is associated
with an increased risk of blood clots.
Talk to your doctor
The new guidelines present a good opportunity for a discussion
about your risk for heart disease with your physician. Ask about
your risk based on the guidelines' new risk formula, and ask about
your HDL, LDL and triglyceride levels and whether any changes
in lifestyle or medication are indicated.
Dr. Setaro is an attending cardiologist at Yale-New Haven
Hospital and Yale-New Haven Heart Center, as well as an associate
professor of medicine and director of the Cardiovascular Disease
Prevention Center at the Yale University School of Medicine.