Click here for YNHH home page.


Sign up for HealthLINK.

Can we help?

Follow up on this month's He@lthLINK

 


Phone Numbers

Directory assistance
(203) 688-4242

Patient information
(203) 688-4177

Adult emergency
(203) 688-2222

Children's emergency
(203) 688-3333

Admitting
(203) 688-2221

Children's admitting
(203) 688-3331

Psychiatric admitting
(203) 688-9907



Mailing address:
Yale-New Haven
Children's Hospital
20 York Street
New Haven, CT
06510-3202





Yale-New Haven Hospital, New Haven, Connecticut, USA HealthLINK: Pediatrics
July 31, 2002

News this month
Eye drops as effective as patching?

For years, patching a child's “good” eye to strengthen the weaker one has been the standard practice. But now, a new study suggests that using eye drops to blur vision in the good eye is as effective in many cases as patching. This alternative is also easier to use for many children who are resistant to the discomfort and embarrassment that comes with wearing a patch.

A new study suggests that using eye drops to blur vision in the good eye is as effective in many cases as patching.

Making new connections to sight
In March, the Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group published in Archives of Ophthalmology the results of the eye patch vs. drops trial to treat moderate amblyopia in children. Amblyopia is a medical term of Greek origin that means “dullness of vision.” It has been referred to as “lazy eye.”

Treatment has traditionally involved patching the good eye so the weaker eye is stimulated to develop. For greatest success, this treatment is best performed on younger children who are still able to respond to treatment with improvement in their vision. Response to treatment after age eight is poor.

What causes weak eyes?
Amblyopia is poor vision in an eye that did not develop normal vision early in childhood. When one eye develops good vision and the other does not, the eye that does not see as well is the amblyopic eye. Amblyopia affects about 3 percent of the population.

Who participated
This study was supported through cooperative agreements with the National Eye Institute and conducted by the Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group at 47 clinical sites in North America. Before entering the study, children had to undergo an eye exam and a check of the eye's ability to move (ocular motility exam).

To participate, children had to be:

  • Younger than seven years old
  • Have visual acuity in the weak eye from 20/40 to 20/100
  • Have visual acuity in the good eye of 20/40 or better
  • Have a measurable difference in acuity between the eyes (3 or more logMar lines)
  • Have a history of strabismus or anisometropia causing amblyopia

Using visual acuity to measure success
Between April 1999 and April 2001, 419 children participated in the study, with 215 in the patching group and 204 assigned drops. The mean age was 5.3 and the group was split evenly between boys (53 percent) and girls (47 percent). Average vision in the weaker eye was about 20/63 at the beginning. Vision in the weak eye of all participants was measured at five, 16 and 26 weeks. After the six-month visit, patients were followed for an additional 18 months.

In the patching group, children had to be patched a minimum of six hours a day, but ideally all waking hours unless improvement was noted. Then fewer hours could be used. In the eye drop group, children received one drop per day. At the five-week visit, both groups received a questionnaire for parents to fill out about the type of treatment. At the six-month visit, the child's poor eye was tested for visual acuity by a health professional who did not know in which study the child had participated.

78% in the eye drop group had excellent compliance with the treatment, compared with 49% in the patch group.

There were major differences in sticking to the treatment regimen, with only 49 percent of children in the patch group having excellent compliance, compared with 78 percent in the eye drop group.

Similar results over time
Although the patching group initially had better results, the differences at six months in visual acuity were small. Seventy-nine percent of the patching group and 74 percent of the eye drop group met the criteria for successful treatment. A patient was considered successfully treated if:

  • The visual acuity in the weak eye was 20/30 or better.
  • The visual acuity had improved three or more lines from baseline.

Physician Referral Online
A free and confidential service
of Yale-New Haven Hospital.

Physician Referral Online
Using your own criteria, you can request information from a database of 900 area physicians who have registered to participate.

Request an appointment
We would be happy to assist you in scheduling an appointment with a member of the hospital's medical staff. Use the link above or call:
203-688-2000
or toll-free
1-888-700-6543
to talk with a referral coordinator.

Martha Howard, MD

Treatment options for amblyopia

In the past, eye doctors have recommended patching the good eye with a self-stick patch that completely blocks vision in order to stimulate the weaker eye. The number of hours the child is told to wear the patch can vary—from a few hours to all waking hours each day. But as you can imagine, children often resist wearing the patch because they can't see as well and the skin can become irritated from the patch.

Children often resist wearing the patch…
as many as half…won't wear it.”

They may be embarrassed to wear it to school and all too often, don't. Past studies have shown that as many as half of the children won't wear it. The best compliance rate has been 87 percent. As a result, children do not gain the benefit of this type of therapy.

Because of these low compliance rates, doctors have been searching for more acceptable alternatives. The idea of an alternative to patching in children age three to seven is very powerful. This study suggests that drops are a good alternative. It's much easier on both the parents who have to give the treatment and the children who live with it.

What goes wrong
Amblyopia is a condition in which a child has a weaker eye from abnormal visual development. There are three major causes of amblyopia: strabismus, unequal focus and cloudiness in normally clear ocular tissue.

Strabismus
In strabismus, a misalignment of the eyes, the eyes appear crossed or one eye is turned out. If both eyes were working normally, the child would see double, so over time the brain turns off the vision in one eye and amblyopia results.

Unequal focus
Refractive errors are eye conditions such as near sightedness, far sightedness, or astigmatism, which are corrected by focusing an object with glasses. When what is seen by one eye is blurred due to not wearing glasses, the blurred eye may stop developing and become amblyopic.

Cloudiness
Another cause is a structural block, such as a cataract, a clouding of the naturally clear lens in the eye. A cataract prevents a clear image from being seen by the eye and can lead to amblyopia.

Signs to watch for in amblyopia:

  • If a child's eyes are not aligned or straight when you look at them
  • If one eye wanders out or crosses in from time to time independent of the other eye
  • If there is a family history of amblyopia
“All children should have their eyes checked at age four.”

Correction of amblyopia
There is a window during development in which to fix these problems—most notably before age eight. After eight, it is harder to restore vision in the amblyopic eye. Treatment of the good eye with either the patch or drops forces the weaker eye to work harder. The drops work by relaxing the good eye so it cannot focus properly up close. The pupils of the eye are dilated by the drops so protective sunglasses are recommended when outdoors.

If a child does not have an eye that is misaligned, it can be difficult to detect amblyopia since a child can appear to have normal vision with both eyes open. All children should have their eyes checked at age four either by their pediatrician, family practitioner or ophthalmologist, a medical doctor who specializes in treating eyes.

Amblyopia runs in families so if a family member has amblyopia, all young relatives should be checked. A difference in vision between the two eyes can raise the question of amblyopia. Sometimes only glasses are needed, but if the vision is not corrected with glasses alone, amblyopia treatment is necessary.

It's important to note that drops are best for children with mild to moderate amblyopia, in the range of 20/40 to 20/100 visual acuity. For children who have vision worse than 20/100, doctors will advocate patching. Atropine drops are not as effective in these cases.

The key to this treatment is compliance and in looking at the questionnaire the parents in the study had to fill out, it was clear the drops were easier to use. This study will continue for two more years so I'll be watching for those results in the future. In the meantime, it will definitely change the way I practice, although there are some children who will hate the drops and prefer the patch.


Dr. Howard is an attending physician in pediatric ophthalmology at Yale-New Haven Children's Hospital.


2002 Best Hospital--U.S. News Online

Yale-New Haven was recognized this year by U.S. News & World Report for its pediatric services.

 

Other related links.


Copyright 1999-2008.
Top of Page. Y-NHH. YNHHS. Site Editor.
Home page
Staff directory
Directions and parking
Online resources
Yale New Haven Health System
  Need a doctor?
Search
Comments
Top of page
Yale-New Haven Medical Center